“How was your day dear.” – the place of story and narrative in our lives

800px-Blind_monks_examining_an_elephant

“A number of blind men came to an elephant. Somebody told them that it was an elephant. The blind men asked, ‘What is the elephant like?’ and they began to touch its body. One of them said: ‘It is like a pillar.’ This blind man had only touched its leg. Another man said, ‘The elephant is like a husking basket.’ This person had only touched its ears. Similarly, he who touched its trunk or its belly talked of it differently. In the same way, he who has seen the Lord in a particular way limits the Lord to that alone and thinks that He is nothing else.”

This story is told in many cultures all over the world – see other versions HERE

INTRODUCTION:

It is difficult to exaggerate the importance of story/narrative, both in life generally and in my SunWALK model in particular.  We are a set of stories.  We live in sets of community-stories.  We mature according to the stories to which we subscribe.  Planning is just a projected narrative.  The past we choose to have is a story adjusted.

In the SunWALK (human-centred studies) model stories are

the glue that makes of the parts a whole

the means for structuring experience in communities

bridges for the flow of culture

the primary act of mind

sources of healing and mystical at-one-ment and connective flow

sources of imagination and creativity

the means by which we come to understand who we are and what we represent

where the three forms of truth-telling can come together – the poetic, the objective and the moral

the means for constructing education cetred on being human, in the world with others

the means for creative the curriculum framework

STORY and NARRATIVE:

Stories Lives Tell; Narrative and Dialogue in Education
is a study of the centrality of narrative in the work that teachers and other educators do. The three themes of the book are central to the SunWALK model. They are: that story and narrative are primary tools in the educator’s work; that education requires one to take seriously the quest for life’s meaning and the care for persons; and that narrative and dialogue can serve as teaching and learning models that transcend the boundaries of disciplines, professions, and cultures.
Witherell, Carol and Noddings, Nel, (Eds.) (1991) Stories Lives Tell; Narrative and Dialogue in Education, NY: Teachers College Press

MYTHS:

“…man is in his actions and practice, as well as in his fictions, essentially a story-telling animal” MacIntyre takes the view that we/humanity are in the midst of a story & that is through the story/ies that we understand each other and ourselves. MacIntyre p 201

Storytelling according to Chinua Achebe, the Ibo novelist is “the basis of our existence – who we are, what we think we are, what people say we are, what other people think we are.” John Windsor The Inde 20.8.94

Myth is where the Muse lives – it is from here we get our creativity. We need to experience life as a poem.

Through mythology we are not seeking truth we are seeking an experience of being alive in a great wholeness. Aunt Jane.

All stories consist of – Exposition:Conflict:Resolution

Narrative has been described as a primary act of mind; children construct their world through story…. This process should be an active experience, involving questioning, problem solving, hypothesising and imagining.’ Cox Report English 5-11, Nov. 1988

FIRST SITUATION Man in the World and with The World, Nature and Culture – Freire

“Through the discussion of this situation – man as a being of relationships – the participants arrive at the distinction between two worlds: that of nature and that of culture. They perceive the normal situation of man as a being in the world and with the world, as a creative and re-creative being who, through work, constantly alters reality.” – Paulo Friere, p.63, Education: The Practice of Freedom

FROM ‘HARD TIMES’ a novel by Charles Dickens

This tells everything about holism, and the three voices of being human – the Creative ‘I’ voice, the Critical ‘I’ voice and the Caring-moral ‘WE’ voice;

“Its father as calls me Sissy , sir,” returned the young girl in a trembling voice, and with another curtsey.

“Then he has no business to do it,” said Mr Gradgrind. “Tell him he mustn’t. Cecilia Jupe. Let me see. What is your father?”

“He belongs to the horse-riding, if you please sir.” Mr Gradgrind frowned, and waved off the objectionable calling with his hand.

“We don’t want to know about that , here. You mustn’t tell us about that, here. Very well, then. Describe your father as a horsebreaker. He doctors sick horses, I dare say?”

“Oh yes, sir.”

“Very well then. He is a veterinary surgeon, a farrier and horse-breaker. Give me your definition of a horse.”

(Sissy Jupe thrown into the greatest alarm by this demand.)

“Girl number twenty unable to define a horse!” said Mr Gradgrind, for the general behoof of all the little pitchers. Girl number twenty possessed of no facts, in reference to one of the commonest of animals! Some boy’s definition of a horse. Bitzer yours.”…………………..

Bitzer,” said Thomas Gradgrind. “Your definition of a horse.”

“Quadruped. Graminivorous. Forty teeth, namely twenty-five grinders, four eye-teeth, and twelve incisive. Sheds coat in the spring; in marshy countries, sheds hoofs, too. Hoofs hard, but requiring to be shod with iron. Age known by marks in mouth.” thus (and much more) Bitzer.

“Now girl number twenty, said Mr Gradgrind. “You know what a horse is.”

SOME ADDITIONAL SOURCES

http://www.stevedenning.com/What_story.html

Ver: 8th July 2009

Do you remember when all the world was a giant ice-cream?

This wonderful, simple, perfect, timeless photograph by Benn Mitchell is on the Boca Raton Museum of Art. 

bennmitchellgirleatingicecream

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The museums blurb says this; 

Color Me New York – Photographs by Benn Mitchell
Through January 18, 2009

The exhibition honors Benn Mitchell as a forerunner in realistic photography, documenting life in New York City during the 1930s through the 1950s. Mitchell (born in New York City 1926 – ) sold his first photograph to LIFE magazine at the age of 16. Just one year later he became a portrait photographer in Hollywood for Warner Brothers’ studios, capturing classic images of Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall, among others. In 1948, Mitchell started his own commercial studio in New York City, the beginning of a career lasting over five decades. This exhibition presents 16 color images shot in the streets of New York City between 1947 and 1980, which capture Benn Mitchell’s acute observations, and his award-winning eye for both the artistic and the incidental. Mitchell now lives with his wife Esther in Boca Raton
.

 

To go to the museum’s site click HERE

Click HERE to have your say about this…

Click HERE to have your say about this article –  at SEESMIC  video discussion

We enjoyed immensly our visit to Unveiled: New art from the middle-east at London’s Saatchi Gallery.  This ‘review’ is about Ghost by Kader Attia – and how it is great work – including for teachers or home-schoolers.  (Exhibition ends 9th May 2009)

 

kader_attia_ghosts_2

Kader Attia – Ghost – 2007 – Aluminium foil – Dimensions variable – Saatchi Gallery, London

In Ghost, a large installation of a group of Muslim women in prayer, Attia renders their bodies as vacant shells, empty hoods devoid of personhood or spirit. Made from tin foil – a domestic, throw away material – Attia’s figures become alien and futuristic, synthesising the abject and divine. Bowing in shimmering meditation, their ritual is equally seductive and hollow, questioning modern ideologies – from religion to nationalism and consumerism – in relation to individual identity, social perception, devotion and exclusion. Attia’s Ghost evokes contemplation of the human condition as vulnerable and mortal; his impoverished materials suggest alternative histories or understandings of the world, manifest in individual and temporal experience. (This is the gallery description)

-0-

Draft Notes for suggested lessons:

I always admire simplicity – creating a profound piece just by wrapping aluminium foil around a room full of kneeling women – great simplicity.

Presence and absence – traces – how and it what ways do people live on.

Why might the artist have called the piece Ghost as opposed to Ghosts?  Which do you prefer and why?

What makes a person a person?

Which bits of the gallery description of Ghost make good sense to you  – and which don’t – and why?

Two of the most important concerns in a person’s development are 1) identity – who am I? and 2) purpose – what am I dedicating my life to?  What has Ghost to do with identity and purpose?

How powerful might it be if, as a performance piece, a real live woman came and filled one of the places?  Would you dress her in aluminium or not – how else would you dress her?  Would she speak to the audience?  What would she say?

The aluminium creates boundaries, forms – of people who were/are/aren’t no more.  Is there spirit to go with the form – or not?  If so what is it – where is it – whose spirit is it?

What are your feelings about the women whose forms gave rise to the ghost/s?

How might a fundamentalist respond to this piece?  How might a modern believer respond to this piece?  

Create a conversation betwen two such people.  

What would the whole thing be like if the women had been from Christian/Jewish/Hindu/Buddhist etc background?

What conclusions do you come to as a result of viewing the photograph  – or better still having visited the exhibition?

How would you use your/the above ideas to make your own art?

Palestininan woman and Israeli soldier – photograph by Noel Jabbour

I loved the teasing ambiguity of this photograph at Boca Raton Museum Of Art – dare we hope that something good might, just might, be passing between them – some kindness instead of cruelty, some recognition instead of hatred?  Is the hand about to become a fist?  Is she touching his chest in an appeal such as she might make to her son? Does the ambiguity shift the photograph from documentary to fine art?  Does the space created by the ambiguity make the art? 

paelestinian-woman-israeli-soldier-noel-jabbour

 

—–0—–

 Have you seen the SunWALK human-centred studies model? – summary HERE 

A slide version of the SunWALK holistic education model – on what it is to be fully and positively human

A slide version of the SunWALK holistic education model – on  what it is to be fully and positively human:

 

HERE

 

.

Great Educators: Matthew Lipman's PFC – Philosophy for children

matthew-lipman-sidelit

Professor Matthew Lipman – founder of Philosophy for Children (PFC)

.

Videos of PFC Philosophy for children

NB – I have been asked by Dr McCall to point out that ALL the videos are HERS not Prof. Lipman’s – and there was me thinking that she had learned PFC from Lipman!

.

Lots more on YouTube under ‘Philosophy for Children’

Free – thousands of online books and audiobooks

listening-recording-deviceSOURCE – see here for a wonderful site on texting and SMS

1) Whilst looking for an e-copy of Dickens Hard Times I came across this amazing site that provides MP3, downloadable versions of classic books and much else – free audio-books – Librivox.

The Librivox catalogue starts HERE

2) The Librivox material was on an even more astonishing site the Internet Archive

The Internet Achive is about;

The Internet Archive is a 501(c)(3) non-profit that was founded to build an Internet library, with the purpose of offering permanent access for researchers, historians, and scholars to historical collections that exist in digital format. Founded in 1996 and located in the Presidio of San Francisco, the Archive has been receiving data donations from Alexa Internet and others. In late 1999, the organization started to grow to include more well-rounded collections. Now the Internet Archive includes textsaudiomoving images, and software as well asarchived web pages in our collections. 

3) What an amazing age in which we live – at least in terms of learning and communication – SAVE THE INTERNET

Reading Barthes – some points about the point or punctum of photography

richtersfmomareading1
Lesende (Reader), 1994 Oil on linen Collection SFMOMA, purchased through the gifts of Mimi and Peter Haas and Helen and Charles Schwab, and the Accessions Committee Fund © Gerhard Richter.

The famous book Camera Lucida by Roland Barthes, about the nature of experiencing a photograph, refers to  his depth of feeling about a photograph we never see, a photograph of his mother.  This picture Lesende (Reader) affects me considerably, but not as much as one of my mother as a young woman leaning on her bicycle.  It affects me for reasons I can bring to mind, but also affects me beyond such reasoning.  (At first I thought it was a photograph – it is an oil painting in just one of Richter’s extraordinary range of styles.)  We are much more than what we think, we are, in addition to that which is known, a mystery – even to ourselves.

The depth of affect (feeling) is determined by the subject, that is by the unique admixture of experiences and personal history each of us has had.  But of course most have experiences in common; pleasure, pain, loss etc.  The personal history is what determines the exact nature of the punctum, the ‘pain’ we feel when we are grabbed, held and moved by an art object.

Photographs then , or more accurately the experience of them,  are created, like other forms of communication, from what the viewer brings added to what the artist provides.  That is we ‘read’ a work of art with a combination of what is there, objectively, and what we subjectively bring.

It makes sense to refer to a) the affective resonance as compared to b) the cultural provision by the particular art work.  Or the punctum and studium as per Barthes.

‘Resonates’ seems apt because it is a kind of shaking or spasm or feinting – depending on the surprise and depth of the aesthetic experience.  We say, “It resonates with me, or “It didn’t resonate with me.”  When there is a perfect alignment between the elements of the art object and our subjective self we are ‘swept away’, ‘riveted’, ‘the earth moves’, ‘we cease to exist’ (at least as a reasoning objectifying entity), we are stunned, speechless etc.

Of course the artist/photographer had his/her own co-equivalent to the punctum – the germ and urge to en-form some movement of spirit.

In narrative terms the above picture by Gerhard Richter sets up a host of possibilities – is she reading exam results, a newspaper story, a letter from a friend…… But that is not what takes us in the first place nor we return from the unitive experience of our first encounter is it such possibilities that are the really interesting philosophical  payoffs.

For me it is that we are reading, just as she is reading, and it is the intensity of the focus in her reading – the set of her mouth and jaw that creates the power of the piece.

We are also on the edge of intrusion, in the tension of personaal and social space.  That’s the punctum for me, that’s where the resonances are.   Where are they for you?

SOURCES

Barthes’s Punctum – Michael Fried

What Do We Want Photography to Be? A Response to Michael Fried – James Elkins

LESSON POSSIBILITIES

You need to know more about what Candida Lucida says – start with WikiPedia article.

1 Find different reproductions of the painting – what difference does it make?

2 How would you name and explain punctum and studium in a more accessible language?

3 Have a look at Richter’s other work – an extraordinary range of styles.

4 Do philosophical inquiry lessons (PFC) on the major concerns of the article.

5 Make your own pictures of the Reader picture.

What are your own ideas for yourself or your class.

SOME QUESTIONS

What is a Camera Lucida and why might it have been a metaphor for Barthes

How and in what way is each mind, or soul, a Camera Lucida?

Is the use of a camera Lucida cheating?   (See the whole debate started by the painter David Hockney)

What are your own questions for yourself or your class?

—–0—–

 

Reading Barthes

Women artists: Eva Zeisel – and aesthetics as the playful search for beauty

—–0—–

Eva Zeisel – a 100-year  life-time’s design rooted in a ‘nature and human relationships’ aesthetic.

I’m not interested in innovation.” (Eva)

They are so beautiful – like a symbol of eternity!” (Blog commentator)

Zeisel’s Rockland BowlZeisel’s Rockland Bowl

Her TED presentation;

The ceramics designer Eva Zeisel looks back on a 75-year career. What keeps her work as fresh today (her latest line debuted in 2008) as in 1926? Her sense of play and beauty, and her drive for adventure. Listen for stories from a rich, colorful life.

Eva’s  story is indeed as interesting as her work – for more see HERE

There is a documentary about her (2002) HERE

Amazon have several books about Eva, and vases etc designed by her,  HERE

Courtesy of TED

Photo and comments source Metropolismag Mason Currey

—–0—–

Some questions to include in a school, college or university project on 

Women artists: Eva Zeisel – and aesthetics as the playful search for beauty

Is Eva a designer, an artist or both.

She seems to a) have created beauty and b) been commercially successful against great odds AND impervious to the ‘art-mafia’ that run the fine art world.’  Discuss.

Google Robert Hughes and ‘The Mona Lisa Curse’ – what relevance do you see between the Hughes analysis and the achievement of Eva Zeisel?

Should schools, colleges and universities make a greater effort to find people like Eva who seem to connect to that which is eternal, beyond fashions?